I agree on both sides. The "needed" school supplies cost about $20 when hitting the back to school sales. All the rest- backpacks, clothes... buy throughout the year as you can afford it. Kids don't NEED new clothes to start the school year. Kids shouldn't be made to suffer because their parents SUCK!
@squidgirl : If you can actually buy the entire list for $20, color me surprised. You are correct that new clothes and a new backpack are not *needed* (unless the child outgrew their clothes which happened with my kids quite frequently and their backpack is worn out from several years of use).
OTOH, this is the 7th/8th grade list (the k-4 list is a pdf)
12 pack of #2 Pencils
2 of each Blue, black, & red pens (no gels)
Notebook paper
Graph paper
1 Ruler (inches/centimeters ruler)
1 Handheld pencil sharpener 1
1 4-pack highlighters (different colors)
Scissors (3" - 4" in size)
8 Glue sticks ( 4 of 8 for Science)
1 Package of manila paper
1 8-pack of markers
1 12-pack of map pencils
1 Package construction paper
2 Package Post-Its
1 Package 3 ½ x 5 index cards
5 Colored folders with pockets and brads (blue and red required)
2 Composition notebook (100 pages preferred)
1 Large 3 ring binder w/zipper
1 3 subject 11" 8 ½ " spiral with pocket dividers
2 Three-subject spiral
2 Packages of dividers
2 Folders with brads
2 *Boxes of tissue
1 *8oz. hand sanitizer
1 Recommended: pencil bag for supplies
Note that 12 pencils will probably last about 1/4 of the year if that, 6 pens likewise. Depending on what math you are taking the graph paper may last 1/2 the year or the entire year. We never bought tissues or hand sanitizer when I went to school, but the schools no longer supply those. Likewise I never had to buy manilla paper or construction paper - the school supplied that.