Yes, Texans actually pay more in taxes than Californians do
Yes, Texans actually pay more in taxes than Californians do
‹ BackThis discussion has been locked.
Joined:
X days ago
# Posts:
X,XXX
Contributor Points:
X
Yes, Texans actually pay more in taxes than Californians do
While ITEP's findings were compiled from 2018 data, one expert says not much has changed in Texas over the last four years.
Texas politicians and CEOs often tout the state as "low-tax" because workers here aren't forced to pay the local government a percentage of their income, in contrast to places like California. However, recently resurfaced data shows that may only apply if you're a wealthy resident here. A popular post recently shared on Reddit's main economic forum displayed a graphic that explained how Texans actually pay more in taxes than Californians do, unless those Texans are in the top one percent of all earners. The graphic reportedly contains 2018 data from the Institute of Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), which compiled statistics regarding IRS income tax, sales tax, property tax, and information from Bureau of Labor Statistics' Consumer Expenditure Survey from sources including the U.S. Census Bureau, according to a report by the San Antonio Express News. The graphic also contained a watermark from the Instagram account Progress for the People, which creates similar infographics for the social media platform. The graphic was posted to the account in May along with some context in the caption, which read: "California has the most 'equitable' state/local tax structure in the US, while Texas has the 2nd least. Despite right [wing] propaganda to the contrary, Texas is not low tax for the people most in need. They only care about reducing taxes for the rich, not about helping the poor and creating an equitable system." According to ITEP, Texans whose salaries fall into the lowest 20 percent of income earners (making less than $20,900 annually) pay about 13 percent of their income in state and local taxes. Meanwhile, Californians in the bottom 20 percent (making less than $23,200 annually) pay 10.5 percent. In Texas, the middle 20 percent of income earners ($35,800-$56,000) pay 9.7 percent in state and local taxes in contrast to middle income Californians ($39,100-$62,300), who only pay 8.9 percent. Most glaringly, the top 1 percent of earners in Texas ($617,900 or more) pay 3.1 percent of their income in contrast to top earnings in California ($714,400 or more) who pay 12.4 percent. ITEP also ranked Texas as the second-most regressive tax state, behind Washington State, due to low-income taxpayers bearing a disproportionate share of the tax burden, according to the nonprofit. In contrast, California was ranked the most progressive tax state because residents in higher tax brackets predominantly pay higher tax rates. Robert Peroni, a tax professor at the University of Texas at Austin School of Law, told the Express News that despite these findings first being published four years ago, not much has changed in the Lone Star State in relation to taxes. Peroni added that states with income taxes, like California, actually do more to lower inequality.


Texas politicians and CEOs often tout the state as "low-tax" because workers here aren't forced to pay the local government a percentage of their income, in contrast to places like California. However, recently resurfaced data shows that may only apply if you're a wealthy resident here. A popular post recently shared on Reddit's main economic forum displayed a graphic that explained how Texans actually pay more in taxes than Californians do, unless those Texans are in the top one percent of all earners.
Replies:
And yet people are fleeing California like rats off a sinking ship! Hmmm.
@Magnolia832 .. If Californians Want to live here ... then could this escalate to
them taking over the republican cities ?? Oh how I wish we could go back 3 years
when things were all going so great....
them taking over the republican cities ?? Oh how I wish we could go back 3 years
when things were all going so great....
Let's compare California's state income tax to Texas….oh,that's right,we don't have a state income tax!
I read this last night in mainstream media, and in TX the lowest income pays the most, $ wise, and the billionares pay the least. I mean, the Elon Musks pay 3%, that's outrageous. I was never a fan of a flat rate, but I'm beginning to see it.
But no State Income Tax...that's probably a big difference...also lets work in the cost of living...and the fact that Californians are jumping ship for Texas...all those tourists towns are no more...never going there again...
And this is what texas gets for it's low taxes . www.usnews.com/news/ best-states/texas
if you believe this i have a nice igloo in the desert for sale. compare the value of 1$ from here to there and maybe you can see. in California i would be " the poor" because the cost of living and value of money is different. "According to ITEP, Texans whose salaries fall into the lowest 20 percent of income earners (making less than $20,900 annually) pay about 13 percent of their income in state and local taxes. Meanwhile, Californians in the bottom 20 percent (making less than $23,200 annually) pay 10.5 percent. In Texas, the middle 20 percent of income earners ($35,800-$56,000) pay 9.7 percent in state and local taxes in contrast to middle income Californians ($39,100-$62,300), who only pay 8.9 percent. Most glaringly, the top 1 percent of earners in Texas ($617,900 or more) pay 3.1 percent of their income in contrast to top earnings in California ($714,400 or more) who pay 12.4 percent." ^^ here we are talking about a 2-3% tax difference who would like to bet that you don't lose more than 3% of your currency value by passing that imaginary line into California? Taxation is theft no matter if you are poor or rich. tax the politicians seem to be a better stance than taxing the rich.
you cannot tax or print your country into a utopia . The best operation system, is free market capitalism with low regulation . Peroni can have all the pieces of paper up on his wall he wants it doesn't make him smart or maybe just a liar who knows better.
you cannot tax or print your country into a utopia . The best operation system, is free market capitalism with low regulation .
in fact lets get into the cost of living www.bestplaces.net/c ost-of-living/dallas -tx/los-angeles-ca/6 5000 while utilites were 6.3% less
and healthcare was 8.3% less in California than Texas
the over all cost of living was 74.5% more
food was 5% more
housing was 221% more
cost to own a home was 240% more
and transportation was 41.2% more so i have to pay 2-3% more in taxes but have about a 70% ( lets give cali a few percent to be nice) in my cost of living
dang Texas you so bad ! why not help the poor people! this cost of living difference says a lot about the amount of regulations put in by each state and how that relates to each states productivity . In 2019 California would have been the 5th largest economy in the world if it was its own nation and Texas would have been the 9th. so they are comparable but a 70% cheaper cost of living with a smaller economy?!?! man someone must be doing something right! whoever posted this on Instagram either has a small brain or is a decent liar they have fooled 4963 people.
and healthcare was 8.3% less in California than Texas
the over all cost of living was 74.5% more
food was 5% more
housing was 221% more
cost to own a home was 240% more
and transportation was 41.2% more
dang Texas you so bad ! why not help the poor people! this cost of living difference says a lot about the amount of regulations put in by each state and how that relates to each states productivity .
@damascus1986 :
I could not afford to live in cali, even if I wanted to live there- which I never would. They're nuts!
I could not afford to live in cali, even if I wanted to live there- which I never would. They're nuts!
@HillCountry : agreed 100% its almost a different country in my opinion
@HillCountry :
Wages are higher in California
Wages are higher in California
@damascus1986 :
Definitely no person on earth is retiring in cali. Atleasr I wouldn't think anyone would want to.
Definitely no person on earth is retiring in cali. Atleasr I wouldn't think anyone would want to.
@Magnolia832: I'll stay right here in Texas!!
@HillCountry : California is a big state and there are some good retirement options there if you can afford them.
Del Mar (suburb of San Diego)
Larkspur (suburb of San Francisco)
Seal Beach (suburb of Los Angelos)
Corta Madera (suburb of San Francisco)
Piedmont (suburb of Oakland)
Palos Verdes Estates (suburb of Los Angelos)
There are other places that are not suburbs of the big towns as well.
Del Mar (suburb of San Diego)
Larkspur (suburb of San Francisco)
Seal Beach (suburb of Los Angelos)
Corta Madera (suburb of San Francisco)
Piedmont (suburb of Oakland)
Palos Verdes Estates (suburb of Los Angelos)
There are other places that are not suburbs of the big towns as well.
This discussion has been locked.
« Back to ChatViews: 1,044
# Replies: 20










